RC-Monster Forums

RC-Monster Forums (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/index.php)
-   Brushless (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   why is a neu better than a feigao? (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/showthread.php?t=23470)

littlegiant 09.11.2009 07:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zeropointbug (Post 319786)
Just to elaborate on the laminations a bit more... the laminations play a large role in the efficiency of there small motors because when you have a magnetic field at a decent frequency on a piece of iron, it will heat up, it heats up because it causes 'micro turbulence's' within the field and causes little whirls of current, or 'Eddy currents', these currents are basically micro shorts, which are doing NO work, and making only heat as the biproduct (also affects magnetic strength a small amount). The higher frequency you go, the more heat is created in this manner, basically a linear curve, that's why when you add enough cells to a setup the rpm's increase, and this causes lot's of heat buildup, in particular a feaiaiago motor is cursed with this symptom. This happens because iron is conductive... NOW, if we were to make very thin sections of this iron and electrically insulate each lamination with a resin/bonding agent, then the Eddy currents are much smaller, and thus less heat is created, and less energy wasted equals more energy to make motive power, hence a more efficient motor.

Just plain tolerances/quality control make a better, more efficient motor as well, which the feiaiaiaieiegao's are missing.

Shouldn't there be a sticky post on this kind of stuff here? This is RCM! :mdr:

Does this mean that Air core motors suffer no iron loss since there is no iron cores in them?

Arct1k 09.11.2009 11:21 AM

no one mentioned that the neu motors are black...

nitrostarter 09.11.2009 11:58 AM

And some are smooth and others are ribbed. Pick your please.

ANGRY-ALIEN 09.11.2009 12:13 PM

:lol:

zeropointbug 09.11.2009 12:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by littlegiant (Post 319937)
Does this mean that Air core motors suffer no iron loss since there is no iron cores in them?

Even being an air core motor, there is still iron in them, as a magnetic shield around the stator, which is magnetically coupled to the winds that are contained therein. The rotors of a cheap motor will also be one piece, non-sintered, which also are doomed to the same eddy currents as a crappy non laminated iron stator core, which heats up the rotor. Because the rotor is not directly thermally coupled to anything for active cooling, they just heat up and heat up, and this is another reason why feiago's cannot typically run very long without over heating or burning up. They need heatsiking and fans, which not very many people here like to use. :smile:

SpEEdyBL 09.11.2009 04:17 PM

Actually feigao rotors are sintered. All sintered magnets are one piece that run the whole length of the rotor (except for some feigaos which have two or three magnets next to each other). The process of making them is from bits of magnetic material ground up into a paste, then molded into shape. They can be nickel plated or wrapped, so can't always tell that a rotor is sintered just by looking at it.

Arct1k 09.11.2009 04:23 PM

neu's rotors are kevlar wrapped to whereas Feigaos are not...

Can i add press fit end bell on Feigao too

big greg 09.11.2009 04:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lincpimp (Post 319789)
Yeah, still curious, but not bi-curious like you Harold... I still to women, singles or multiples if at all possible. I even try to make sure the camera-person is female, but that is not always possible.

i can hold the camera and if ya get exausted you can tag me in:wink:

big greg 09.11.2009 05:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arct1k (Post 320047)
neu's rotors are kevlar wrapped to whereas Feigaos are not...

Can i add press fit end bell on Feigao too

half pressed, and not glued. sometimes a slide fit <-- i like the sound of that:whistle:

brushlessboy16 09.11.2009 05:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by big greg (Post 320061)
half pressed, and not glued. sometimes a slide fit <-- i like the sound of that:whistle:

Thats what she said.


Pressed endbells are not a signal to a bad motor. Aveox- the granddaddy of neu, uses some pressed endbell motors and they run just fine.:yes:

zeropointbug 09.11.2009 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SpEEdyBL (Post 320044)
Actually feigao rotors are sintered. All sintered magnets are one piece that run the whole length of the rotor (except for some feigaos which have two or three magnets next to each other). The process of making them is from bits of magnetic material ground up into a paste, then molded into shape. They can be nickel plated or wrapped, so can't always tell that a rotor is sintered just by looking at it.

Are you sure? I know what sintered is, I just didn't think they used it for those rotors. There are sintered and non sintered magnets.

Kcaz25 09.11.2009 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brushlessboy16 (Post 320064)
Thats what she said.


Pressed endbells are not a signal to a bad motor. Aveox- the granddaddy of neu, uses some pressed endbell motors and they run just fine.:yes:


What do you mean the granddaddy of Neu? Educate me.

Arct1k 09.11.2009 06:05 PM

I believe S Nue used to work at/own (not sure which) Aveox and then formed Neu

brushlessboy16 09.11.2009 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arct1k (Post 320080)
I believe S Nue used to work at/own (not sure which) Aveox and then formed Neu

He was a high ranking employee at Aveox, he was one of the head designers of their motors- took the design with him when he left and created neu motors

_paralyzed_ 09.11.2009 08:46 PM

well, hopefully the aveox I just bought off Linc does me well then. I like the natural aluminum can(no anodizing)


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:26 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.