RC-Monster Forums

RC-Monster Forums (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/index.php)
-   Brushless (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Insides of a Plett (in case anyone is interested...) (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/showthread.php?t=13771)

lincpimp 07.24.2008 06:26 PM

Insides of a Plett (in case anyone is interested...)
 
Here ya go, a plett maxximum with his pants down :lol:

It is a 6 pole motor. It has an 1/8 shaft all the way thru, and the bearings are different from my plett maxx w/fan so not too sure about getting a 5mm shaft rotor in there. The front of the can is intergral, so not much chance of getting a bigger bearing in there, without machining.

The polished fin edges were done by me, I like the way it looks better than solid blue...

Very nicely made motor, not sure if I want to sell it now...:whistle:

http://i206.photobucket.com/albums/b...p/DSCF2345.jpg

http://i206.photobucket.com/albums/b...p/DSCF2347.jpg

http://i206.photobucket.com/albums/b...p/DSCF2346.jpg

sikeston34m 07.24.2008 06:28 PM

Well that's pretty cool. I always take stuff apart to see it's innards. LOL

What kv is this?

BrianG 07.24.2008 06:40 PM

Definitely a slotted stator design. The coils look very neat and tidy. And the magnet looks pretty large in diameter compared to a typical 540 Feigao.

lincpimp 07.24.2008 06:41 PM

Somewhere around 3000kv. I have ran it in a crt.5 and a flm pede on 3s, and an emaxx on 4s. Definately has plenty of torque.

I did not play around with the timing much, but plan to try my other maxx w/fan with a variety of settings. That motor is in the new emaxx with a griffinru stage1 mm. I run it with a pair of trakpowers in series for 4s. Current gearing is 18/68, way too low. I will say that the fan can move some air. feels like a hairdryer! I need to gear it up, and increase the timing, as the multipole motors seem to run better with higher timing...

brushlessboy16 07.24.2008 07:15 PM

is there any way to wrap the rotor of a feigao motor with kevlar or CF?

lincpimp 07.24.2008 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brushlessboy16 (Post 194640)
is there any way to wrap the rotor of a feigao motor with kevlar or CF?

Not sure if there is enough room between the rotor and the windings. If there is, you just wind the kevlar string on with a power drill, and then brush some epoxy (or the correct stuff) on the kevlat string. At least that is what I have been told!

snellemin 07.24.2008 07:34 PM

The internals are impressive looking. Thanks for the pics. Wish I could buy it from you.

lincpimp 07.24.2008 07:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snellemin (Post 194647)
The internals are impressive looking. Thanks for the pics. Wish I could buy it from you.

No prob, it is a great motor, that is for sure...

maxair45 07.24.2008 10:57 PM

What esc did you use while it was in the rustler?

lincpimp 07.24.2008 10:58 PM

Mamba Max esc...

lutach 07.25.2008 12:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brushlessboy16 (Post 194640)
is there any way to wrap the rotor of a feigao motor with kevlar or CF?

Yes.

lutach 07.25.2008 12:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lincpimp (Post 194644)
If there is, you just wind the kevlar string on with a power drill, and then brush some epoxy (or the correct stuff) on the kevlar string.

Correct.

lutach 07.25.2008 12:10 AM

Your Pletty looks good lincpimp.

lincpimp 07.25.2008 01:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lutach (Post 194712)
Your Pletty looks good lincpimp.

Thanks Luciano...

Looking at the rotor, it has 12 flats on it that can be felt thru the kevlar wrap. Does that mean it is a 6 pole motor? Or am I missing something: reasonong is that a magnet has 2 poles, and 12 divided by 2 would be 6?

If it is a 6 pole motor, should I run higher timing? Would that improve performance?

lutach 07.25.2008 01:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lincpimp (Post 194725)
Thanks Luciano...

Looking at the rotor, it has 12 flats on it that can be felt thru the kevlar wrap. Does that mean it is a 6 pole motor? Or am I missing something: reasonong is that a magnet has 2 poles, and 12 divided by 2 would be 6?

If it is a 6 pole motor, should I run higher timing? Would that improve performance?

That rotor looks just like the one in my Extreme. They might use 2 magnets per pole. Funny thing you asked about timing. The 6S controller that I've been testing was acting up when I had low timing running the Aveox. When I went to mid timing the controller worked perfect. Now days I'm getting more and more confusing as some companies say to run low timing to keep temps down. I always go mid or 5 degrees of timing for 4 pole motors and high or 10+ degrees for 6 pole motors. My 60A controller burned when I changed timing on it when I was running the Mega ACn16/15/1. I had 15 degrees of timing and it was doing awesome, but I made a mistake and changed the timing instead of another setting and a couple of FETs went dead.

brushlessboy16 07.25.2008 02:15 AM

....where the heck do you get kevlar string?

kostaktinos_mt 07.25.2008 05:46 AM

these are 4pole motors actually...
as mentioned above, slotted stator paired with a multi-pole rotor [armoured via kevlar shell] is the 'basic configuration' for plettenberg car motors...

10-15 degrees of advanced timing will lead to smoother start-ups and enhanced power [for this particular genre of motors]. when combined with a switching rate of 13-19khz, it will also yield the best possible efficiency.

the rotor diameter is 22mm if i recall correctly.

http://i82.photobucket.com/albums/j2...t/100_0306.jpg
http://i82.photobucket.com/albums/j2...t/100_0315.jpg
http://i82.photobucket.com/albums/j2...t/100_0316.jpg
http://i82.photobucket.com/albums/j2...t/100_0320.jpg
http://i82.photobucket.com/albums/j2...t/100_0323.jpg
http://i82.photobucket.com/albums/j2...t/100_0384.jpg

TruckBasher 07.25.2008 05:59 AM

Nice photo, thanks....

I also want to know where to get kevlar stirng and what is the best high temp epoxy to use...

Duster_360 07.25.2008 07:03 AM

kostaktinos_mt - is that a 5mm shaft? Sure looks bigger. Thanks for the pics, you can tekk how well engineered it is the build quality is obvious.

I want one of these to run my UE Lightning when I get it finished, but need a 5mm shaft since its going to be one of my heavier MTs, prob the heaviest.

bdebde 07.25.2008 03:14 PM

I always thought the Pletts were 4 pole, they even have P4 (poles 4?) in the part number. After running my big maxx on the MGM controller and looking at the peak rpm (when set for 4 pole), I get a max rpm of 78,000 on 6s (22.2 volts) in the software. If you convert that over for 6 pole, it would be 52,000 rpm. The big max is supposed to be 2300 kv, so 22.2 x 2300 = 51,060 rpm, which makes more sense and leads me to believe it IS actually a 6 pole motor.

lutach 07.25.2008 11:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdebde (Post 194849)
I always thought the Pletts were 4 pole, they even have P4 (poles 4?) in the part number. After running my big maxx on the MGM controller and looking at the peak rpm (when set for 4 pole), I get a max rpm of 78,000 on 6s (22.2 volts) in the software. If you convert that over for 6 pole, it would be 52,000 rpm. The big max is supposed to be 2300 kv, so 22.2 x 2300 = 51,060 rpm, which makes more sense and leads me to believe it IS actually a 6 pole motor.

The ones that use the P4 are 4 pole motors. Most of the Plettys are 6 poles.

brushlessboy16 07.26.2008 07:54 AM

can some one tell me where to get kevlar string?

sleebus.jones 07.26.2008 10:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lutach (Post 194726)
Now days I'm getting more and more confusing as some companies say to run low timing to keep temps down. I always go mid or 5 degrees of timing for 4 pole motors and high or 10+ degrees for 6 pole motors.

Very interesting, because that's what I've always heard too:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bernie Wolfard
All Castle Creations speed controllers provide dynamic timing advance. This means the advance setting changes with speed and load on the motor to maximize the efficiency of the motor as all speeds. Changing the timing advance setting lowers or raises the range in which timing advance moves. The advance settings actually overlap quite a bit.

Generally, outrunner motors work best with high timing advance. However, one of the motor characteristics CC ESCS compensate for is motor inductance. The high inductance of outrunners pulls timing advance up. This means that for most medium to small outrunners 'Standard' timing advance works well. With these the only reason to lower timing is if the motor is running too hot or if it starts making noise above half throttle. The noise means the ESC is loosing sync with the motor.

With larger outrunners we recommend 'Low' timing advance. The larger the outrunner the higher its inductance. These larger motors inductance pulls our ‘Low’ timing advance up to the higher timing advance these motors want without having the advance get so high that the ESC can no longer sync the motor.

Hope this helps.

Bernie

And the followup:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bernie Wolfard
The difference between medium/small is somewhat subjective as different motors behave somewhat differently. When I wrote the above I was thinking about AXI motors where anything below the 4100 sized would be medium/small, 4100 and up would be large.

However, if you have a large 2800 series motor that makes noise over half throttle lower the advance. It is also a good idea, if you like to fiddle with things, is to change timing between 'Low' and 'Standard' and see if full throttle produces more or less RPM.

To make it easy, as long as the motor is behaving OK don't change timing. If it is making noise at higher throttle settings or running too hot lower timing.

Bernie

I realize this is about outrunners, and we've been discussing inrunners, but I'd like your thoughts/experience too. :yes:

I've only goofed with timing on a outrunner I've got. I never tried higher timing with it, because it got pretty darn warm just on normal, and changing to low (or lowest) didn't help at all. The motor I was trying was a Axial 600XL, now I'm wondering if higher timing might be worth a shot?

Serum 07.27.2008 04:04 AM

http://picasaweb.google.com/buikpijn/Bigmaxximum

and this is what a bigmaxximum looks like.

lincpimp 07.27.2008 04:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Serum (Post 195215)
http://picasaweb.google.com/buikpijn/Bigmaxximum

and this is what a bigmaxximum looks like.

OOOHHH!!!

I really would like to have a Big Maxx, Expecially considering how well the Maxx w/fan runs in my emaxx! I bet that 5s with the big maxx would be a handfull!

TruckBasher 07.27.2008 04:17 AM

I also want one one...but sadly its to pricey :neutral:

Thanks for the picx

Mister-T 07.27.2008 10:28 AM

When you look inside it just like an industrial motor. It's made to last

bdebde 07.27.2008 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lincpimp (Post 195216)
OOOHHH!!!

I really would like to have a Big Maxx, Expecially considering how well the Maxx w/fan runs in my emaxx! I bet that 5s with the big maxx would be a handfull!

And 6s with a big maxx is more than a handful, he he:yes:

bdebde 07.27.2008 09:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brushlessboy16 (Post 194957)
can some one tell me where to get kevlar string?

Google "kevlar thread"

lincpimp 07.27.2008 09:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdebde (Post 195440)
And 6s with a big maxx is more than a handful, he he:yes:

Have you ran one on 6s? I bet that would be crazy...

bdebde 07.27.2008 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lincpimp (Post 195447)
Have you ran one on 6s? I bet that would be crazy...

I have tried it just a little on 6s, waiting for my MMM to get back to give it the real test.

lincpimp 07.27.2008 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdebde (Post 195453)
I have tried it just a little on 6s, waiting for my MMM to get back to give it the real test.

What are you running the motor in?

bdebde 07.27.2008 11:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lincpimp (Post 195455)
What are you running the motor in?

My Muggy

brushlessboy16 07.28.2008 12:05 AM

Videooooo

GriffinRU 07.28.2008 12:31 AM

It is great motor and I still have bad fellings towards Serum he compared this motor with 7XL!!!!!!!

This is the best motor you can get from Germany, even Lehner is nothing to compare.
At the time Sculze was the only one ESC which can handle this motor, but now MGM can do great and I hope MMM and MM with 1.17 software.

You cannot bring feigao to the level of Plett, even if you gold plated it!!!!

Balancing is very important and plett is the best in that area. I had plett's , lehner, feigao 1-4, nemesis, mega, medusa, kontronic, align, axi, aveox ... and none of them can even get close to plett.

It is not advertisement, it is pure facts, if you have budget than plettenberg is the motor for you.

BUT YOU NEED TO KNOW HOW TO UTILIZE 4-6 POLE MOTOR it is not the same as 2-pole and BrinG calculator doesn't work great here either, not that Brian is wrong, it is very unique motor case.

GO PLETTENBERG, all the rest is HYPE - 'TRUE HYPE" not by Patrick

lincpimp 07.28.2008 01:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GriffinRU (Post 195507)
It is great motor and I still have bad fellings towards Serum he compared this motor with 7XL!!!!!!!

This is the best motor you can get from Germany, even Lehner is nothing to compare.
At the time Sculze was the only one ESC which can handle this motor, but now MGM can do great and I hope MMM and MM with 1.17 software.

You cannot bring feigao to the level of Plett, even if you gold plated it!!!!

Balancing is very important and plett is the best in that area. I had plett's , lehner, feigao 1-4, nemesis, mega, medusa, kontronic, align, axi, aveox ... and none of them can even get close to plett.

It is not advertisement, it is pure facts, if you have budget than plettenberg is the motor for you.

BUT YOU NEED TO KNOW HOW TO UTILIZE 4-6 POLE MOTOR it is not the same as 2-pole and BrinG calculator doesn't work great here either, not that Brian is wrong, it is very unique motor case.

GO PLETTENBERG, all the rest is HYPE - 'TRUE HYPE" not by Patrick

Good info Artur. I have had alot of success running my plett motors with quark escs. I will try your mod1 MM with the maxx w/fan on 4s. It is doing fine with the quark 125b, but I prefer the programability of the MM and the lvc settings.

What would you suggest I set the timing at on the MM for the plett? I am guessing that higher timing will be better. Patrick mentioned that the MM auto figures the timing, and the adjustment is in that range, not from a baseline setting. If that is the case, normal timing should work for the plett? Or should I go higher?

Serum 07.28.2008 02:08 AM

Auw, that feels like a stab in the back Arthur. I always considered you where intelligent enough to see things in perspective.

Fact of a matter was that the 9920 and the 7XL preformed the same in my savage than the schulze/bigmaxx setup, so i jumped to that conclusion, considering the schulze setup was more than twice as expensive. my schulze burned, the bigmaxx his bearings where having play after a few runs. the 9920 didn't die on me, it was the entire setup i was impressed about. I guess i didn't know how to utilize the holy setup!

Maybe you can teach us how to utilize a 4 pole motor, and maybe this holy grale pays off.

lincpimp 07.28.2008 02:24 AM

Catfight!!!

GriffinRU 07.28.2008 10:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Serum (Post 195531)
Auw, that feels like a stab in the back Arthur. I always considered you where intelligent enough to see things in perspective.

Fact of a matter was that the 9920 and the 7XL preformed the same in my savage than the schulze/bigmaxx setup, so i jumped to that conclusion, considering the schulze setup was more than twice as expensive. my schulze burned, the bigmaxx his bearings where having play after a few runs. the 9920 didn't die on me, it was the entire setup i was impressed about. I guess i didn't know how to utilize the holy setup!

Maybe you can teach us how to utilize a 4 pole motor, and maybe this holy grale pays off.

No, how I can do that to you, Rene.
The reason I mentioned your name is that any time we talking about plett's your posting with that comparison is always coming to play. And what is clear for you and couple other members here is not that obvious for the rest, while they do remember the BAD comments.
I bought couple used plett's and bearings were great, bearing failure can happen to any motor.
I use plett with MGM and Scultze ESC's, normal timing, geared for 25-30kRPM with 18 cell's NiMh or 5S LiPo. Plett has nice torque curve, but plett wasn't rated for high current and not for wide RPM range (it would spin up to 70000RPM, but temp would go as well).
Haven't use plett with CC controllers, no input here.

Serum 07.28.2008 10:39 AM

It's all good Artur, i was surprised to see your reaction, it must be the language barrier that isn't offering any help either.

The Neu 15151Y motor on the other hand (which could be largely compared to the bigmaxx, 4 pole, same KV) is capable of 6S (according to castle) i wonder what it does on 6S, i can only imagine a drivetrain to go south pretty soon, since it's an incredible powerhouse on 4 and 5S allready.

I spoke to plettenberg on a show in Germany, they claimed the KV of the bigmaxx and the maxximum can be wound different on request (no warrantee though) 1700Kv for the bigmax and 2200 kv for the maxximum.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.