Ebay...to give or not to give....

[BP-Revo]

This guy is an ass hat. Give him a negative.

For me, neutral is when they screwed up, but you would still do business with them again if you had to. Negative is when they sucked so bad you don't want to bother again.

As for the star ratings, I would say be honest on those. If the product description was accurate, give him 5 stars on that. But his shipping and attitude sucked, so give him 1 or 2 stars on those.