A123 M1, 7XL, Quarky E-Maxx project - RC-Monster Forums

zeropointbug · 12.04.2006, 03:01 AM

Oh yah, the A123's you NEED to double them up, you are working them too hard running single cell (it's only 2.3Ah), doing 2p you get 140 amp cont. plus more punch from higher voltage, and more than double runtime.

8s1p running a 12XL would be a monster for sure, but i think you are better off going 6s2p running a 8 or 9XL motor. Which I should have done... i should have got the 8XL running (i got 7XL) 6s2p pack. For more power and runtime.

starscream · 12.04.2006, 03:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zeropointbug

Oh yah, the A123's you NEED to double them up, you are working them too hard running single cell (it's only 2.3Ah), doing 2p you get 140 amp cont. plus more punch from higher voltage, and more than double runtime.

8s1p running a 12XL would be a monster for sure, but i think you are better off going 6s2p running a 8 or 9XL motor. Which I should have done... i should have got the 8XL running (i got 7XL) 6s2p pack. For more power and runtime.

I guess you can call me an efficiency freak because I'd rather get my runtime from higher voltage than running packs in parrallel. I guess I feel that if I'm going to add extra weight by adding cells, I'd rather run them in series and get the benefits from the higher voltage than waste the opportunity by running them in parrallel. 8S will significantly reduce the current needed from the batteries and boost my run time as well. 8S1P should get me well beyond the 15 minute mark for the Mains. 8S1P is lighter than 5S2P and I'd be willing to bet the run time won't be much different. I can't say for certain until I get the opportunity to actually test it. I'm waiting for the esc and I'll post my results. :017:

zeropointbug · 12.04.2006, 03:36 AM

it will be more efficient slightly on the motor end of things, but the batteries will be drawing alot of amps from only single cell. Maybe 8s1p will do for the 12XL, if you are racing, then i guess its sensitive....

starscream · 05:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zeropointbug

it will be more efficient slightly on the motor end of things, but the batteries will be drawing alot of amps from only single cell. Maybe 8s1p will do for the 12XL, if you are racing, then i guess its sensitive....

I must say that I am happy with the run time I am getting from the 6S1P. They seem to deliver more mAh's than what my Lipo's are rated for.

From what I've read, the M1's drop voltage when the current exceeds 50amps or so, thus the need for 2P. My 6S1P setup has just about enough power but the power just isn't quite there. I'm pretty sure that 7S1P (with appropriate gearing) will do the trick. I'll have to wait until the phantom cell becomes available so I can add an extra cell to my soderless power tube for 7S1P.
I am certain that 8S1P will reduce the current needs to a level where the M1's can provide adaquate power because if 4S2P can provide enough current, an 8S1P should cut the current draw in half thus eliminating the need for 2P.
If 8S works well with the 12XL I will most likely go 9S1P and a neu 1515 2Y.